The Sutton Mustangs 2023-24 basketball season was a tale of two season as the Mustangs finished the month of December with a 3-5 record, before winning seven of their next nine games to head into the Southern Nebraska Conference tournament with a 9-7 record, including a six-game winning streak, beating Ravenna, Fairbury, Thayer Central, Milford, and Sandy Creek, and taking down David City in the opening round of the SNC tournament.
Following their 55-51 first round win over the Scouts, Sandy Creek gained revenge on the Mustangs with a 32-24 semifinal win, after Sutton upended the Cougars 38-30 a week earlier.
The loss to Sandy Creek sent the Mustangs to the consolation game with Fillmore Central, with the Panthers claiming a narrow 46-41 win, placing Sutton fourth in the SNC tournament.
Sutton then won two of their final three regular season games with wins over Wilber- Clatonia and Superior, while the Panthers again set the Mustangs back.